Family Encyclopedia >> Entertainment

Top 5 Best Online Movie Rental Services: Amazon, iTunes, Vudu, Google Play & YouTube Compared

Online movie rentals offer convenient access to endless entertainment right from home. Major players like Amazon, iTunes, Google Play, Walmart's Vudu, and YouTube have made it easier than ever. If you're seeking free options, check out our guide to the Top 18 Free Movie Streaming Sites.

With so many choices, selecting the right service comes down to pricing, video quality, selection, and device compatibility. Drawing from years of testing these platforms for family movie nights and personal viewing, here's our expert comparison of the top five.

Unsure what to watch? Get trusted reviews from Rotten Tomatoes, featuring useful tools beyond the Tomatometer.

1. Amazon Prime Video Rentals

Amazon has been our family's reliable choice for Saturday night rentals for years, especially with a Prime subscription unlocking free content.

Movie Selection

Prime offers tons of free movies—see our 8 Cool Things You Can Do With Amazon Prime Video for tips. However, free titles often lean toward older films, B-movies, indies, or lesser-known releases.

Top 5 Best Online Movie Rental Services: Amazon, iTunes, Vudu, Google Play & YouTube Compared

Premium hits require rental fees. Most provide HD/SD options: rent for 48 hours of playback or buy for your permanent library. Access SD via More purchase options to save.

Top 5 Best Online Movie Rental Services: Amazon, iTunes, Vudu, Google Play & YouTube ComparedTop 5 Best Online Movie Rental Services: Amazon, iTunes, Vudu, Google Play & YouTube ComparedTop 5 Best Online Movie Rental Services: Amazon, iTunes, Vudu, Google Play & YouTube ComparedTop 5 Best Online Movie Rental Services: Amazon, iTunes, Vudu, Google Play & YouTube Compared

Viewing Options

Stream instantly from your video library on computers or laptops.

Top 5 Best Online Movie Rental Services: Amazon, iTunes, Vudu, Google Play & YouTube Compared

No native casting from browsers, but use Chrome tab casting to Chromecast. Better yet, use streaming devices like Fire TV Stick—see our guides on the best media streaming devices and how to set up Amazon Fire TV Stick.

Apps for mobile work too, but no direct casting.

Top 5 Best Online Movie Rental Services: Amazon, iTunes, Vudu, Google Play & YouTube ComparedTop 5 Best Online Movie Rental Services: Amazon, iTunes, Vudu, Google Play & YouTube ComparedTop 5 Best Online Movie Rental Services: Amazon, iTunes, Vudu, Google Play & YouTube Compared

Download: Amazon app on Google Play (free) | iTunes (free)

Video Quality

Quality depends on your internet. Stick to SD for slower connections—Android defaults to it.

  • HD: Up to 1080p with 5.1 audio (needs high-speed internet).
  • UHD: 4K resolution (15 Mbps+ recommended).

2. iTunes Movie Rentals

Ideal for Apple users with iPhones, iPads, or Macs. iTunes works on PCs too—try our 7 steps to make iTunes usable again.

Movie Selection

Vast library rivals Amazon and Vudu. Rent for 48 hours or buy; lower-res options available without price drop.

Top 5 Best Online Movie Rental Services: Amazon, iTunes, Vudu, Google Play & YouTube ComparedTop 5 Best Online Movie Rental Services: Amazon, iTunes, Vudu, Google Play & YouTube Compared

Viewing Options

Seamless on Apple devices. Android access is limited by DRM. Use Home Sharing for Apple TV.

Top 5 Best Online Movie Rental Services: Amazon, iTunes, Vudu, Google Play & YouTube Compared

Video Quality

Superior playback fills screens beautifully on Apple hardware, supporting widescreen and high-res displays.

3. Vudu Movie Rentals

Walmart-acquired Vudu in 2010; now a staple on streaming devices. Great backup when others run dry.

Movie Selection

Comparable pricing and selection, plus free ad-supported movies.

Top 5 Best Online Movie Rental Services: Amazon, iTunes, Vudu, Google Play & YouTube Compared

Easy filters for Rotten Tomatoes scores or eras. Free options: "Free with Ads" or "Movies on Us"—over 1,000 titles, some gems amid B-movies.

Top 5 Best Online Movie Rental Services: Amazon, iTunes, Vudu, Google Play & YouTube Compared

Viewing Options

Native Chromecast from web and apps. Supports Roku, TiVo, smart TVs, consoles.

Top 5 Best Online Movie Rental Services: Amazon, iTunes, Vudu, Google Play & YouTube ComparedTop 5 Best Online Movie Rental Services: Amazon, iTunes, Vudu, Google Play & YouTube ComparedTop 5 Best Online Movie Rental Services: Amazon, iTunes, Vudu, Google Play & YouTube ComparedTop 5 Best Online Movie Rental Services: Amazon, iTunes, Vudu, Google Play & YouTube ComparedTop 5 Best Online Movie Rental Services: Amazon, iTunes, Vudu, Google Play & YouTube Compared

Download: Vudu on Google Play (free) | iTunes (free)

Video Quality

SD/HD/UHD options. Smoother casting than Amazon, but higher res needs strong bandwidth.

4. Google Play Movies & TV

A solid latecomer with ample choices and competitive pricing.

Movie Selection

Filter by studio, genre; some free B-movies/documentaries.

Top 5 Best Online Movie Rental Services: Amazon, iTunes, Vudu, Google Play & YouTube ComparedTop 5 Best Online Movie Rental Services: Amazon, iTunes, Vudu, Google Play & YouTube ComparedTop 5 Best Online Movie Rental Services: Amazon, iTunes, Vudu, Google Play & YouTube Compared

Viewing Options

Native Chromecast; wide device support (600+ listed). Intuitive mobile app.

Top 5 Best Online Movie Rental Services: Amazon, iTunes, Vudu, Google Play & YouTube ComparedTop 5 Best Online Movie Rental Services: Amazon, iTunes, Vudu, Google Play & YouTube ComparedTop 5 Best Online Movie Rental Services: Amazon, iTunes, Vudu, Google Play & YouTube ComparedTop 5 Best Online Movie Rental Services: Amazon, iTunes, Vudu, Google Play & YouTube Compared

Download: Google Play Movies on Google Play (free) | iTunes (free)

Video Quality

SD/HD/UHD across devices; reliable casting.

5. YouTube Movie Rentals

Turn here for variety when options elsewhere dwindle.

Movie Selection

Searchable by genre/title; plentiful rentals matching Amazon prices. Weak filters.

Top 5 Best Online Movie Rental Services: Amazon, iTunes, Vudu, Google Play & YouTube ComparedTop 5 Best Online Movie Rental Services: Amazon, iTunes, Vudu, Google Play & YouTube Compared

Viewing Options

Rent via trailer button; 48-hour window. Native Chromecast; mobile app convenience.

Top 5 Best Online Movie Rental Services: Amazon, iTunes, Vudu, Google Play & YouTube ComparedTop 5 Best Online Movie Rental Services: Amazon, iTunes, Vudu, Google Play & YouTube ComparedTop 5 Best Online Movie Rental Services: Amazon, iTunes, Vudu, Google Play & YouTube ComparedTop 5 Best Online Movie Rental Services: Amazon, iTunes, Vudu, Google Play & YouTube ComparedTop 5 Best Online Movie Rental Services: Amazon, iTunes, Vudu, Google Play & YouTube ComparedTop 5 Best Online Movie Rental Services: Amazon, iTunes, Vudu, Google Play & YouTube Compared

Download: YouTube on Google Play (free) | iTunes (free)

Video Quality

Full SD/HD/UHD support; clean players with casting and queue options.

Top 5 Best Online Movie Rental Services: Amazon, iTunes, Vudu, Google Play & YouTube Compared

Which Is the Best Online Movie Rental Service?

All deliver reliable quality. Choose by your ecosystem:

  • Apple fans: iTunes.
  • Google/Android/Chromecast: Google Play.
  • Amazon Prime: Amazon rentals (many free).
  • Variety seekers: Vudu or YouTube.

It's a golden era for movie lovers—fire up your devices! For free streaming, see our best free movie sites.